KS3 · English

Analysing a Shakespeare character

Two characters on one island, both bound to Prospero. One is freed. The other is left behind. So which one is the 'monster'? Look closely and neither label survives.

The Tempest · Ariel and Caliban

What do they share, and what splits them?

Decide who each feature fits: Ariel, Caliban, or both. Tick every circle that applies, then check against the play.

  • A Ariel
  • B Caliban
  1. Is forced to serve Prospero
  2. Is threatened by Prospero
  3. Is insulted by Prospero
  4. Uses magic to stop a plot to kill Alonso
  5. Helps stop the plot against Prospero in Act Three
  6. Appears as a harpy at the magical banquet
  7. Has no gender assigned, and we know little about how they feel or look
  8. Is freed by Prospero at the end of the play
  9. Was the island's only human inhabitant before Prospero and Miranda arrived
  10. Plots with Stephano and Trinculo to overthrow Prospero
  11. Is called hag-seed and hag-born
  12. Is left alone on the island at the end (the lesson's reading)

Prospero and Ariel

Is Prospero cruel to Ariel?

The claim

Shakespeare presents Prospero as cruel to Ariel.

Place each piece of evidence to load the balance. Mark the strong ones — they count double.

  1. When Ariel asks for freedom, Prospero accuses Ariel of lying.

    Evidence 1: does it support or challenge the claim?
  2. Prospero calls Ariel a 'malignant thing'.

    Evidence 2: does it support or challenge the claim?
  3. Prospero threatens to trap Ariel in a tree again if Ariel keeps complaining.

    Evidence 3: does it support or challenge the claim?
  4. As he promises freedom, Prospero calls Ariel 'my Ariel'.

    Evidence 4: does it support or challenge the claim?
  5. Prospero reminds Ariel that he freed them from imprisonment.

    Evidence 5: does it support or challenge the claim?
  6. Prospero never actually hurts Ariel.

    Evidence 6: does it support or challenge the claim?
  7. Prospero promises to free Ariel after more tasks.

    Evidence 7: does it support or challenge the claim?
  8. In the end, Prospero does free Ariel.

    Evidence 8: does it support or challenge the claim?

Same relationship, two stagings

Ariel floats above ProsperovsProspero stands over Ariel

Tap each insight to see what the change in staging does.

Focus

Positioning

Ariel floats above Prospero

Ariel is higher up

Prospero stands over Ariel

Prospero is higher up

The insight

It is the same two characters in the same play. The only thing that has changed is who is higher.

Who seems more powerful

Ariel floats above Prospero

Ariel seems more powerful

Prospero stands over Ariel

Prospero seems more powerful

What else a director could use

Ariel floats above Prospero

Body language, costume or make-up that backs up Ariel's power

Prospero stands over Ariel

Body language, costume or make-up that backs up Prospero's power

Caliban

Monster, victim, or something harder to sum up?

Caliban was the only human inhabitant of the island before Prospero and Miranda arrived. By the time the play is under way, Prospero has forced him to be a slave.

Which of these is closest to what you think about Caliban right now?
How sure are you?

English Lit · Paragraph craft

Build a paragraph about Ariel

Tap each slot to see the sentence that does its job.

The Tempest · How does Shakespeare present Ariel?

Tap a slot to fill or empty it.

Selected slot

Tap a slot above

Watch out: 'Alternatively' is a signpost, not a magic word. The second reading still needs evidence behind it.

Your turn

Give Ariel or Caliban a voice

Before you write, jot down two or three notes: what has your character been through, and what do they feel about it?

Write a short monologue (four to six sentences) in Ariel's or Caliban's voice about serving Prospero. A monologue is a long speech by one character, often a memorable moment where they express their inner thoughts. [5 marks]

0 words · your answer stays on this page and is not sent anywhere.

WHAT YOU'VE LEARNED

A quick recap of today's lesson.

How Shakespeare presents two characters bound to Prospero, and how you can write about them with evidence.

What you need to know

  • To analyse a character, ask three questions: what do they do in the plot, how do they speak, and how are they spoken to?
  • Ariel is magical and does Prospero's bidding, like creating the tempest. That Prospero told Ariel to do it shows he is in control.
  • Have a goYour classmate says: 'Ariel creates the whole storm, so obviously Ariel is the one in charge.' Does the storm prove that?

    No. Prospero told Ariel to create it, which shows Prospero is in control of Ariel.

    Doing the work is not the same as giving the orders, and the plot shows who gives them.

  • Ariel's magic helps stop the plots against Alonso and against Prospero.
  • Ariel's language shows both deference and frustration: eager to do Prospero's bidding, but bluntly asking for liberty.
  • Prospero answers with reminders, accusations and threats, and Ariel is forced to be obedient because of them.
  • Have a goAriel ends up obeying Prospero. Does that mean Ariel is happy to?

    No. Ariel is forced to be obedient.

    Obeying on the surface is not agreeing, because the reminders, accusations and threats are what keep Ariel in line.

  • Caliban was the island's only human inhabitant before Prospero arrived, and their relationship began positively.
  • Have a goAnother friend says: 'Caliban was Prospero's enemy from day one.' What fact sinks that?

    Their relationship began positively: Caliban showed Prospero how to survive on the island.

    Caliban's story starts with friendship, not hostility, which is why one hostile label is too simple.

  • Prospero captured Caliban and forced him to be a slave, threatening him with magic and physical violence.
  • The language around Caliban is violent and negative, which shapes how the audience sees him.
  • Staging (body language, positioning, costume and make-up) can change how an audience reads a relationship.
  • Strong analysis uses short quotations, zooms in on words, and offers alternative interpretations with words like 'alternatively'.

The big picture

Ariel and Caliban are both bound to Prospero: forced to serve, threatened and insulted. Ariel helps Prospero and is freed; Caliban plots against him and, in this lesson's reading, is left alone. To write about either, ask what they do in the plot, how they speak and how they are spoken to, then use short quotations and offer an alternative reading.

Key points

1Ariel and Caliban share the way Prospero treats them (forced to serve, threatened, insulted) but not their roles or endings.
2To analyse a character, ask what they do in the plot, how they speak and how they are spoken to.
3Prospero's treatment of Ariel can be read in more than one way: Shakespeare presents Ariel as mistreated and exploited, and also presents Prospero's kindness because he ultimately frees Ariel.
4Caliban cannot be summed up in one word: the relationship with Prospero began positively, then became slavery, and Prospero says that followed Caliban trying to hurt Miranda.
5Staging, such as who stands higher, can change which character seems more powerful.

Worked example

Problem

Use the three questions to analyse how Ariel is presented when asking Prospero for freedom.

⚠ Watch out

Summing a character up in one word: 'Ariel the obedient spirit', 'Caliban the monster'. The details say otherwise: Ariel shows frustration and is threatened by Prospero, and Caliban's story began with friendship.

🧠

Memory hook

Do, say, be told: what they DO in the plot, how they SAY it, and how they are TOLD what to do. Then ask who is standing higher.

✓

Check yourself

Pick one moment from the play. Which of the three questions does it answer, and what does it make you think about Prospero?

Flashcards

(15)
What three questions help you analyse how a character is presented?
What is their role in the plot (and how does the audience react at each point)? How do they speak? How are they spoken to?
What is staging?
The manner of performing a play. Body language, positioning, costume and make-up all influence how the audience understands the relationship between characters.
In the sleep scene, who plots to kill Alonso, and how does Ariel stop them?
Antonio and Sebastian plot while Alonso sleeps. Ariel wakes Gonzalo, who sees them with their swords drawn.
How does Ariel help stop the plot against Prospero in Act Three?
Invisible, Ariel imitates Trinculo's voice to insult Caliban and cause tension, then plays magical music to lead the plotters away.
What is a harpy?
A mythical creature with a human face and upper body and the wings and lower body of a bird, said to be an agent of punishment.
Why is Ariel open to the audience's own interpretation?
We know very little about how Ariel feels and looks, and no gender is assigned to Ariel.
What might it suggest that Prospero has more lines than Ariel in their conversation?
That his voice is considered more important. Lines and stage directions both matter when analysing a play, not only the words.
What does 'my Ariel' suggest?
That Prospero feels he owns Ariel, even as he promises freedom.
How does Caliban's relationship with Prospero begin?
Positively. Caliban showed Prospero how to survive (shelter and safe foods) and Miranda taught him language.
What does Caliban swearing to be Stephano's servant suggest?
How desperate Caliban is to get away from Prospero. Stephano shares his alcohol with him first.
How does Caliban's plot against Prospero end?
It fails. Stephano and Trinculo are distracted by stealing fine clothes and Prospero's magical dogs drive them off. Caliban returns to Prospero's service and the three are ordered to clean and tidy the house.
What do 'hag-seed' and 'hag-born' remind the audience about Caliban?
That he is the son of a witch. A hag is an old woman who practises witchcraft.
Why is Caliban one of the most analysed characters in The Tempest?
Because of what he could represent in terms of colonialism and how Shakespeare's society viewed colonialism.
What makes a quotation work well in an analytical paragraph?
It answers the question and supports the topic sentence. Individual words and short quotations are often more effective than whole sentences, and you zoom in on them.
How do you write a convincing monologue in a character's voice?
Plan first, match the tone to the character's experiences, choose adjectives and verbs carefully, use metaphors for emotions, and use short sentences for heightened emotion such as anger.

Tap any card to flip it, or use Study as deck to go through them one at a time. In the full lesson these run as a spaced-repetition deck — you rate each card Hard, Good or Easy and the tricky ones keep coming back until they stick.

Learning with Lightbulb is opening soon

You can use this lesson now. Join the waitlist and we'll let you know when the full Lightbulb experience is ready.

Keep me posted

More KS3 English topics

See the full KS3 English curriculum →

How this lesson was checked. This KS3 Englishlesson was published through Lightbulb Learning's human-designed editorial process — the educational standards, accuracy rules and publication checks it must pass were authored and approved by Philip Halpin. It passed subject-specific assessment, automated educational checks and technical publication verification before going live (publication checks completed 7 November 2026). Published pages are monitored, human spot-checking is ongoing across the lesson library, and anything found wrong is corrected or withdrawn. How our lessons are made and checked. Spotted a mistake? Email hello@lightbulblearning.co and we'll review it.

Helpful guides for parents and students